Crack the rule No equipment

Psychiatrist

The group secretly agrees on a rule for answering questions. One player has to work out what it is.

the best bit: realizing everyone's been answering as the person on their left

Players
5–15 (best with 6–10)
Time
15–40 min
Learn in
Seconds
Mood
Lively
Format
One vs. everyone
Teach mode: one step at a time

The 30-second version

One player, the Psychiatrist, leaves the room. Everyone else agrees on a secret rule for answering questions, like answering as if they were the person on their left. The Psychiatrist comes back and asks anyone anything until they can name the rule.

honestly, just read this out and go.

Grab these

Nothing at all. just your people.

Set up

  1. Pick someone to be the Psychiatrist and send them out of the room.
  2. Everyone else picks a secret rule for how they'll answer questions. For your first game, use one from the list below.

How to play

  1. Ask anything

    The Psychiatrist comes back and asks people questions, one at a time: "What did you have for breakfast?" "Where did you grow up?"

  2. Answer by the rule

    Everyone answers following the secret rule, and tells the truth wherever the rule allows.

  3. Shout "Psychiatrist!"

    If someone gets the rule wrong, anyone can shout "Psychiatrist!" Then everyone gets up and switches seats, which makes rules about where people sit much harder to spot.

  4. Diagnose

    The Psychiatrist can guess the rule at any time. Keep going until they get it, then someone else takes a turn.

How to win

Nobody keeps score. If your group wants a winner, count how many questions each Psychiatrist needs. Fewest wins.

Rules to try

From experience…

If you liked this